Home of the Indian American Family

NRI Pulse Online Magazine is looking for featured bloggers to write on topics of interest to the global NRI. Do you enjoy expressing your thoughts, ideas and opinions on matters close to your heart? Do you have a passion for the arts, politics, women's issues, teenage issues, NRI issues or sports?
Write to us at blogs@nripulse.com to be our featured blogger.
 

Indian Marriage - Friendship or Business Contract?

Print the article

This entry was posted on 4/13/2006 9:20 AM and is filed under Women.




BY MAYA NAIR


The other day, an office friend sent me the link to a news item. A married man
in India had inadvertently mentioned the "divorce" mantra in his sleep!! And now,
the elders in his community claim that the marriage is annulled!
 
Another news item claims that in Rajasthan, a declining sex ratio has altered the conditions of arranged marriages. The girl's parents rejects offers of marriage from men unless the potential groom's family also has a marriageable daughter for their son.

Barter, trade or pure business dealings?
 
Recently, the local newspaper also added to this "marriage for business" controversy by declaring that divorces occur more only when people go into marriages with the expectations of lasting love. In olden days, marriage used to be for purely business and physical reasons, and though the partners strayed from the relationship, they rarely broke up in public.
 
As a malayalee girl growing up in Kerala, I was amused at the history of Kerala women, Nairs in particular. The practice of polyandry and polygamy prevailed in kerala before 1912. In south Malabar, women got respect if she had more lovers. It was customary that this number should not exceed ten or twelve!! the men used to arrange their turns and also divide expenses. When a woman returned the clothes and shoes :)  that were given to her by the man at the beginning of the relationship
(called sambandham), the relationship was over. The children are brought up in the tharavad or joint family. The men live in their ancestral homes and "visit" the wives only at night. Wow, what a system! And then we had the British come in and spoil everything!!! :)
 
The vast majority of marriages in India are still arranged business and social contracts between the families, with the marriage partners barely seeing each other before tying the knot. Although in the metropolitan cities, this may not be so evident, the vast majority of India lives in villages where the gun of "reputation" is still used to silence many of the youth who happen to fall in love with the "wrong person" usually of a different religion, caste or status.
 
Though falling in love is the main theme of Indian movies, in most Indian marriages, the main theme is falling out of love, if indeed there was a brief attraction some time  between the marriage and the first baby. I admit that some of these arranged marriages do work, especially if the partners do not have high expectations of it. But do they ever experience the spontaneity of falling in love? They probably do, but are not bold enough to take a step outside of society's acceptance boundaries.
 
Whenever we go to India on vacation, it was a given fact that we would stay at with my husband's family. This was solely because of the irrational belief that a woman should give up everything once she marries, to the point of forgetting her own home!. How easy it is to accept unreasonable expectations forced on you by the masses.. "don't cause trouble - why can't you be like everyone else?"!!
 
Dowry system is thriving underground. Very few brides have the guts to destroy the family "reputation" by breaking off a marriage based on greed. Magazines are full of advertisements where the bride can barely stand because of the weight of all her jewellery! Imagine what this does to people with small incomes! One can only hope that aborting female babies, dowry deaths and the system of dowry itself will soon vanish into history!
 
Working women everywhere still take hundred percent of the responsibility of child rearing.  Even if the women earn the same or more than their husbands, it will be many many years before Indian society begins to understand what a true marriage should be - a relationship based on love and respect and true equality for women and men.

 

What did you think of this article?




Trackbacks
Trackback specific URL for this entry
  • No trackbacks exist for this post.
Comments

    • 4/18/2006 2:45 PM Molly wrote:
      Good article. You go Mayae....very proud of you.
      Reply to this
    • 4/18/2006 4:57 PM Shreelata wrote:
      Good one, Maya! Way to go girl!
      Reply to this
    • 4/18/2006 7:54 PM Swapna wrote:
      Well written, Maya. Loved it!!
      Reply to this
    • 4/18/2006 7:57 PM Latha Iyer wrote:
      Excellent article Mayae. You know once we start the discussion on this subject, we can go for days! I am so proud that you are my friend.
      Reply to this
    • 4/18/2006 9:50 PM Ganga wrote:
      Good one, Mayae! I love your style! I am planning to live that long to see men and women have equal rights and resposibilities in an Indian family! Hope it won't be that long!
      Reply to this
    • 4/19/2006 6:20 AM Beena wrote:
      Great article Maayae...The day will come, if it has not already started, when men and women in a family shares equal status both in responsibilities and rights. The view of the parents bride and groom still need to change to bring forth changes in a marriage.
      Reply to this
    • 4/20/2006 11:13 AM Sonali wrote:
      Excellent article,keep them coming....
      Reply to this
    • 4/20/2006 11:14 AM Nisha wrote:
      So... I can't marry a guy unless he has a brother for Nitya? Nitya isn't going to be happy about this.
      Reply to this
    • 4/20/2006 11:26 AM Padmaja wrote:
      Very proud of you Maya. No matter how much we pretend like both men and women are equal in our society, its not going to change until we introspect ourselves. This article makes you think about it. Keep on writing.
      Reply to this
    • 4/20/2006 1:03 PM Rajalekshmi wrote:
      Very interesting. Keep writing.
      Reply to this
    • 4/20/2006 4:55 PM Sudeshna wrote:
      Maya, the women in pre-1912 south Malabar had the good life!
      Reply to this
    • 4/20/2006 9:08 PM Kalamandalam Radhika wrote:
      Excellent article.Written like a true nair woman.Why dont we women unite and live like the pre-1912 women.
      Reply to this
    • 4/21/2006 3:55 PM Gita wrote:
      Maya,
      Read your view points with interest.
      Here are my ramblings

      I do agree with your view points on Indian marriages conceptually but not in its entirety. Love is something that should be cherished and nurtured over the years with good amount of effort from both the partners. I agree the spontaneity can be lost in arranged marriages and in love marriages. Lot of Indian marriages do not work or fail within the four walls of a house, marriage can become a loveless prison not because the individuals are not compatible but because the partners refused to acknowledge each other's presence from the very beginning. In love marriages there are additional factors.....

      http://blogs.nripulse.com/2006/04/21/bethechange.aspx


      Reply to this
      1. 4/26/2006 12:21 AM Narender Reddy wrote:
        Gita: Your comments are the most balanced and practical I read on this blog.

        Narender
        Reply to this
    • 4/23/2006 3:52 PM Rekha wrote:
      Maya, Very well written. enjoyed reading and looking forward to more ....
      Reply to this
    • 4/26/2006 12:14 AM Narender Reddy wrote:
      It is an Interesting perspective by Maya Nair on the status of Indian-Marriages. I thought, this was a blog for all readers and not just a ‘women’s forum’. What happened to all those Indian-American men? Did they simply surrender their rights guaranteed under First amendment of US Constitution or simply they chose to plead ‘Fifth’ so as not to incriminate themselves and face the wrath of their ‘better half’ at home..

      Franklin D. Roosevelt said ‘ there is nothing to fear but ‘wife’ it self’. I’ve no such fear waiting for me at home and shall express my opinion freely.

      Indian women have come a long way, from being the victims of abuse by their husbands and in-laws to fight back. Only problem is, today, some of them have gone too far. They became more aggressive to the extent that they are repeating the same crimes that they accused the Indian men of. In many Indian-American house holds, I see men are practically having no voice and are even scared of their wives. I’ve seen, house wives belittling their professional husbands as ‘incompetent’ and ‘worthless’.

      I see in many Indian-American households, only ‘her’ parents living with them or visiting frequently from India.. The message is very clear…’his’ parents are not welcome’. ‘My extended family is our family now – your extended family is, history’. I know of many couples where only she could send money to help her parents/siblings in India but he is prohibited from doing the same thing.

      Sure, these days, both men and women are working and contributing to the financial strength of the household. and sharing household chores and attending to needs of their children.

      I, for one, attended to my infant children’s mid-night feedings religiously and changed equal or more number of diapers than their mother. Both my daughters had long hair. I learned and braided their hair till they reached their pre-teen years. I did it, because I strongly believed in equal parenting and my daughters love me for that.

      Whether, in a love marriage or arranged marriage it is the personality of those individuals that makes the difference in making that marriage a success or failure. It is the willingness on their part to work as a team to reach that common goal of preserving happiness in their lives rather than trying to control each other’s life. How can fear of wife make him love her more? Can fear and love travel in parallel lines?.

      Only, if the couple could learn to live every day as if there is no tomorrow and willing to cherish those memories - life will be wonderful.

      My message to Indian women, as President Kennedy said ‘Ask not what your husband can do for you – ask what you can do for him’ and I gurantee you that life will be wonderful – for him, of course. I’m just kidding.

      Now I’m wearing my armored gear and ready to face all those bricks that Indian women would throw at me..

      Narender Reddy

      (My apologies to Presidents Kennedy and Roosevelt)
      Reply to this
    • 4/26/2006 11:56 AM Dr Indrani Dutta-Gupta wrote:
      I was raised in a different part of India than the previous 2 bloggers and thought I'd send you my tuppence.
      Bengal was where Sati-Daha or widow burning was first abolished. Today when I go back, I see all old traditions still at play, but also, differences. An important difference is the large percentage of women choosing who they marry. A second difference is, how women maintain their maiden or original names--literally unheard of in Bengal 25 years ago. The reasons are many. A previously held passport, a name on the mark sheet or grade sheet from University days, and even some eminence achieved in a profession, can be used as a reason not to give up one's own name. The men's families are now much more flexible. In other words, this is a huge change or progress.

      The quality of the bridal trousseau has improved; however, now it is due to the bride's demand or her mother's demand than the groom's family's demand. It is the same with the gold. It is obvious that, with women inheriting family wealth and property more equitably than before, the groom's side puts less pressure on the bride's side for exact items of the trousseau--but the bride, being often more educated, tends to exert her opinion much more.

      Also, i notice that more and more of the well-adjusted husbands not only listen to their wives more, but often give up their own voices and opinions in order to keep their wives happy!

      Those who don't, are in for a lifetime of unhappiness.

      Indrani
      Reply to this
    • 4/29/2006 9:44 AM Indrani Dutta-Gupta wrote:
      Sounds like a fun activity for those who think and love to write.
      Reply to this
    • 5/1/2006 1:44 PM Anonymous wrote:
      One of the comment describes this as a "fun activity", may be carelessly chosen words! But that is what exactly I see. That is where I've disagreement with these type of NRI blogs where it is just functioning as "intellectual carping" of the writers and means nothing to the cause.

      There is not anything new in these articles other than restating the well known issues at hand. I believe the underlying reason is poverty and lack of education. In Kerala, non-dowry movement is dying even with the proclaimed success in education. Most of the educated women enjoys the comfort (gold, car, money) their parents offer and go with the flow and still do well with their life. They do not see many failures or idealist standing up against the system nowadays. In Kerala it is not a burning issue in the society as it was in decades ago and I think the blogger still lives in that era.

      The rape, inequalities and discrimination occurs when you don't understand what your right is and don't fight for it. This requires grassroots effort in education, jobs and financial stability for women. Also willingness to standup against it when it comes to you. In India women who are reacting to these issues have a financial background to sustain the aftereffects. Those who don't have the financial stability are just going alone with the ride.

      Also I'm not sure if our generation would be same way if our parents had executed their instincts as they felt!
      What Indian women needs is education, job and a helping hand to gain that. May be some role models too… Can we do something about it? Everything else will fall in place appropriately.

      Most of us separated from India by taking citizenship elsewhere and still thinks that we are part of India and Indian issues. There is an India that we don't know exists who doesn’t understand blogs, don't feel they are human beings, without education, without food and water! As we age and vanish in our new country the Indian problem will still exists and will be debated just like these without any meaning. Only positive outcome is the false comfort we gain by talking and debating about it!
      I suggest three old commentary by Jay Dubashi:
      http://iw.sify.com/home/dhan/news/y2k1016-jay.html
      http://www.samachar.com/features/160902-fpj.html
      http://www.rediff.com/business/1999/jan/13dubash.htm
      Reply to this
    • 9/15/2007 8:13 PM Rakesh Simha wrote:
      Dear Maya
      I know that as a woman you are looking at those pre-1912 day with nostalgia. But what Nair women were up to in those days was prostitution by another name. Sambandham was the name given by the rulers and Brahmins to copulate with Nair women and enjoy pleasure without "polluting" themselves as per the perverted caste system.

      It was a way out for Kerala's effete rulers to have sexual relationships with Nair women without the responsibility of having to bring up the illegitimate children that would be a direct consequence of such affairs.

      It was also an easy way to sidestep the untouchability issue. By Brahmanic law in Kerala, a Nair could not come within 8 feet of an uppercaste, so marriage would be unthinkable. Sambandham, therefore, allowed such relationships.

      What happened was that the allure of easy money, land grants, gold and gifts bestowed by the rulers and Brahmins in exchange for the right to have sex with them became an addiction for the Nairs. It became easy money.

      I have several Nair and Menon friends and I am bemused (and amused) when they say they are from the royal family.

      What actually transpires is that they are offspring of Nair women as a result of Sambandham. They really can't use the surname or family surname of their upper caste fathers.

      So let's not call it an enlightened society. It was pure trade. Sex for money and bragging rights in the communal brawl.
      Reply to this
    • 3/20/2009 6:34 AM Preethi wrote:
      Hi, I happenend to see this write up by chance since I am a Menon girl myself and have been fascinated by the Sambandham marrigae practised in Kerala a long time ago. I agree that Sambandam was exploitation by the Nambudhiris but the fact is it was also Pro-woman and it helped the malalyali woman/girls to be as powerful as she could be compared to her counterparts in the other parts of the country. She had a right to agree or disagree to an alliance and could remarry and even had property rights! Polyandry and polygamy all have their ills and I would not like to go back to that era but I personally feel the worst for Nambuthiri women who suffered the most in that system. Of course the new era has none of the problems and hopefully marriages will continue to be union of two hearts and not business transactions. Whether they are love or arranged, marriages need a lot of adjustment by both spouses for its success.
      Reply to this
    • 11/24/2009 12:55 AM Ashley Alfred wrote:
      In view of the increasing number of cases where NRI husbands deserting their Indian brides were being easily let off by overseas
      authorities, the government has decided to hold discussion on the legalities of the issue with local authorities in five countries.
      Reply to this
    • 12/8/2009 12:49 AM Ashley Alfred wrote:
      Though stray incidents keep appearing in the media to focus public attention on the plight of about 12,000 women in the region ill-treated by NRI husbands, they fail to trigger any concerted effort towards checking the problem. When these abandoned wives were given a common platform, they found strength in their common pain.

      watch watchindia.tv
      http://www.watchindia.tv/landingpage/1008/general_ft_box_ht.aspx
      Reply to this
    • 12/20/2009 3:21 AM natural remeides wrote:
      Indian Marriage - Friendship or Business Contract?
      Hello MAYA NAIR,
      I think it's business & marriage is a ladder
      Reply to this
    • 1/19/2010 12:32 PM weight loss pills wrote:
      Considerably, the article is in reality the greatest on this noteworthy topic. I agree with your conclusions and will eagerly look forward to your next updates. Saying thanks will not just be sufficient, for the wonderful clarity in your writing. I will immediately grab your rss feed to stay privy of any updates. Pleasant work and much success in your business dealings!
      Reply to this
    • 1/23/2010 5:03 AM gambling bible wrote:
      I had a great time reading around your post as I read it extensively. Excellent writing! I am looking forward to hearing more from you.
      http://www.gambling-bible.com
      Reply to this
    • 2/3/2010 1:01 AM escorts wrote:
      Hi,


      Why didn’t I find this post earlier? Keep up the good work!
      Reply to this
    • 2/3/2010 11:41 PM classy escort sydney wrote:
      Hi,
      Very useful info. Hope to see more posts soon!
      Reply to this
    • 3/1/2010 11:24 AM childrens toys wrote:
      I feel a lot more people need to read this, very good info!
      Reply to this
    • 3/9/2010 12:11 PM kavita wrote:
      I had an arranged marriage to an Indian man in 1984. I am an Indian American who grow up in a small town in USA. I was naive and gullible. I thought that my husband would love ME, not HIMSELF. He is a control freak who lies, is sneaky and critical and abusive. He does this to me and the children only. With others, he is so nice. It is unbelievable! I am so unhappy with him. Everyday, I think of leaving him. I am waiting for my kids to earn money as I am a stay at home mom. My husband is an emotionally retarded person. I feel that he used me to come to the US and he had no intention of loving me. He buys whatever he wants, goes on trips when he wants and gives to his family whatever he wants. I am not allowed to do anything without his backlash. Please don't blame me and think that it is my fault. There is so much that he has done. I can't even begin to write about that here. He completely devalues me. I have self esteem issues and have tried to improve myself but constant criticism and belittling have worn me down. I am 200lbs and have arthritis all over my body. I am in physical pain as well as emotional pain. I will NEVER advise anyone to have an arranged marriage. It is a TRAP and the woman is usually the victim. Its hard to get out when you have children and no job.
      Reply to this
    • 3/15/2010 1:06 AM female sex toys wrote:
      Hi,
      You really know your stuff... Keep up the good work!
      Reply to this
    Leave a comment

    Submitted comments are subject to moderation before being displayed.

     Enter the above security code (required)

     Name (required)

     Email (will not be published) (required)

     Website

    Your comment is 0 characters limited to 3000 characters.